Dr. Dickie
Member
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2020
- Messages
- 363
Okay, I am harvesting a couple of thousand 1865 LG M26 cells. While I wait on my Megacell Chargers, I am using two Opus BT - C3100 V2.2 testers.
To speed up the process I have two MiBOXER 8-Bay Smart Chargers that I use. One is to charge 8 cells up before putting them in the Opus to be discharge tested, and the other is to charge the tested cells coming out of the Opus back up after discharge testing--that way I can test 3 times as many cells.
Unfortunately, being a noob, I was not really paying close attention to the SOC of the cells when first charging them up (I have been doing this for the last few of hundred). They are mostly between 2.8 and 3.0 V at the beginning. I assumed (wrongfully) that the charger would let me know if a cell was too low to be charged (one of my chargers did this in the past--perhaps the Litto I used early on). I have now found out that if the battery is excessively discharged, this Miboxer will revive the cell and charge it up.
This morning I was putting in some cells that had been sitting for probably a month or two since being harvested and noticed that one had only 0.4V. Yikes. I pulled it out and set it aside.
Long intro, now finally to my questions:
1) Am I correct in thinking that an 1865 cell discharged to 0.4V is trash?--certainly not a cell I would want to put into a DIY powerwall, even if after being revived it charged and discharged showing a good capacity?
2) I am assuming this cell self-discharged to the 0.4V state (the packs they came out of are 10S2P), and so when I get ready to build my pack, I will be able to identify the bad cells because they will have self-discharged to a lower voltage than all the other cells after a couple of months?
3) If the above is not true, is there a way to tell these bad cells from good ones after they have gone through a charge-discharge-charge cycle? Or do I just have to put them into my packs and wait for them to fail
Thanks for the help!!
To speed up the process I have two MiBOXER 8-Bay Smart Chargers that I use. One is to charge 8 cells up before putting them in the Opus to be discharge tested, and the other is to charge the tested cells coming out of the Opus back up after discharge testing--that way I can test 3 times as many cells.
Unfortunately, being a noob, I was not really paying close attention to the SOC of the cells when first charging them up (I have been doing this for the last few of hundred). They are mostly between 2.8 and 3.0 V at the beginning. I assumed (wrongfully) that the charger would let me know if a cell was too low to be charged (one of my chargers did this in the past--perhaps the Litto I used early on). I have now found out that if the battery is excessively discharged, this Miboxer will revive the cell and charge it up.
This morning I was putting in some cells that had been sitting for probably a month or two since being harvested and noticed that one had only 0.4V. Yikes. I pulled it out and set it aside.
Long intro, now finally to my questions:
1) Am I correct in thinking that an 1865 cell discharged to 0.4V is trash?--certainly not a cell I would want to put into a DIY powerwall, even if after being revived it charged and discharged showing a good capacity?
2) I am assuming this cell self-discharged to the 0.4V state (the packs they came out of are 10S2P), and so when I get ready to build my pack, I will be able to identify the bad cells because they will have self-discharged to a lower voltage than all the other cells after a couple of months?
3) If the above is not true, is there a way to tell these bad cells from good ones after they have gone through a charge-discharge-charge cycle? Or do I just have to put them into my packs and wait for them to fail
Thanks for the help!!
Last edited by a moderator: