several question about the powerwall

Yves

New member
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
19
I would like to know the following :
- in a 3 phase network : how do you setup the batteries. So far I've only found information about a mono phase network.
- how are the batteries setup per pack (series/parallel)
- what is the typical charging current/voltage coming from the panels ?
 
- in a 3 phase network : how do you setup the batteries. So far I've only found information about a mono phase network.
3phase? 3phase system?
Its the same battery pack for that system. For instance im using the 10kw hybrid inverter from MPP that is 3phase out. ie 3*230v out. Same battery pack.

- how are the batteries setup per pack (series/parallel)
It totally depends on what inverter and or system you choose and how many cells you have. Im going with 14s. Ie 14 packs in series of 18650 cells. Those cells are 3.7v nominal.
How many in paralell depends on how many cells you have and how many kWh you want. Im currently have 3 strings of 14s80p.


- what is the typical charging current/voltage coming from the panels ?
You don't charge from the panels directly. You have a charge controller in between. MPPT prefered since its a lot more effective.
And what voltage and current a solar panel can deliver totally depends on which one you choose!


Then you set the charge controller to the voltage depending on type of battery bank you have and if you have more solar than your battery could handle you limit the output current from your charger to the battery (If you choose one that can do this)
 
daromer said:
- in a 3 phase network : how do you setup the batteries. So far I've only found information about a mono phase network.
3phase? 3phase system?
Its the same battery pack for that system. For instance im using the 10kw hybrid inverter from MPP that is 3phase out. ie 3*230v out. Same battery pack.

- how are the batteries setup per pack (series/parallel)
It totally depends on what inverter and or system you choose and how many cells you have. Im going with 14s. Ie 14 packs in series of 18650 cells. Those cells are 3.7v nominal.
How many in paralell depends on how many cells you have and how many kWh you want. Im currently have 3 strings of 14s80p.


- what is the typical charging current/voltage coming from the panels ?
You don't charge from the panels directly. You have a charge controller in between. MPPT prefered since its a lot more effective.
And what voltage and current a solar panel can deliver totally depends on which one you choose!


Then you set the charge controller to the voltage depending on type of battery bank you have and if you have more solar than your battery could handle you limit the output current from your charger to the battery (If you choose one that can do this)

I see that I needed to explain the 3 phase network : I'm talking about a 3X400V + N. So in between each phase there is 400 V and between each phase and the N there is 230 V.
 
Yves said:
daromer said:
- in a 3 phase network : how do you setup the batteries. So far I've only found information about a mono phase network.
3phase? 3phase system?
Its the same battery pack for that system. For instance im using the 10kw hybrid inverter from MPP that is 3phase out. ie 3*230v out. Same battery pack.

- how are the batteries setup per pack (series/parallel)
It totally depends on what inverter and or system you choose and how many cells you have. Im going with 14s. Ie 14 packs in series of 18650 cells. Those cells are 3.7v nominal.
How many in paralell depends on how many cells you have and how many kWh you want. Im currently have 3 strings of 14s80p.


- what is the typical charging current/voltage coming from the panels ?
You don't charge from the panels directly. You have a charge controller in between. MPPT prefered since its a lot more effective.
And what voltage and current a solar panel can deliver totally depends on which one you choose!


Then you set the charge controller to the voltage depending on type of battery bank you have and if you have more solar than your battery could handle you limit the output current from your charger to the battery (If you choose one that can do this)

I see that I needed to explain the 3 phase network : I'm talking about a 3X400V + N. So in between each phase there is 400 V and between each phase and the N there is 230 V.

That's not a domestic incoming supply ?
 
Hmm 3*400v?? If its 230v between phase and N its 3*230v ;) Its a normal 3phase system that. (230v) That will give you 400v between the phases.

No matter if you use 3*pip4048 and run them for 3 phases or if you just go with a 3 phase directly like the Hybrid you still only use 1 battery bank connected. No matter if you got 3 units or 1. (This is the most common though)

Here is how mine is connected kind of. Its 3phase:


image_afocaq.jpg


And here you can see how it looks if you paralell several inverters:
http://www.mppsolar.com/v3/pip-ms-series/

You can run several banks if you like but there is no practical need if they are going to supply the same network after.

Hope that clarify your questions somewhat.
 
Thank you for that. Very informing.

Now, for the more practical side. I currently have 2 SMA converters, one of 3000 W and one of 4000 W working with an array of 7000 W in solar panels.
The issue is that I cannot throw just them out as is. The reason being, that they are registred at the time when the installation was checked for conformity and for the susidies. We also get taxed on the power the inverters have.

These 2 inverters are each connected to one phase. Now since my LS board has the 3 phases distributing power evenly to the circuits in our house, I think (with a few exceptions)I would have to connect them to the 2 phases that are currently connected to my inverters, so that I use the maximum of what they produced in house and not sent the power to the grid. (reason being that we get paid less for our solar power than we have to pay when we use the power from the grid).

These 2 inverters have a safety feature that only lets them work when there is power from the grid.

So when keeping these inverterswhat are my options ?
 
Im not sure what a "LS board" is?

Build a system a side that you migrate to is my recommendation...
Regarding the power its same here where you dont get paid half of what it cost to buy it back....

But you can also design a system that when you have excess power feed that into battery bank. That battery bank have inverter tied to it and connected either to the 3rd phase or to something usefull.

Then when you want you could move over pv array to that new "inverter" if its a type that could handle pv too...
SMA also have batter connected stuff but i have very little knowledge in their sortment im afraid.

Check my most AWESOME picture :D




image_ruzdiz.jpg
 
Yves, if you are embarking on an attached battery project in the expectation of saving a pile of money please do the maths before you commence - you won't save money (but you'll enjoy the project)

If you want to make productive use of the surplus PV generation I would suggest that a far simpler method would be load diversion to water heating, or any resistive space heater - there are numerous products that will do this very simply and (unlike a battery bank) will have a positive RoI.

If you want provide your home with energy during an incoming grid failure, buy a generator and fit a changeover switch.
 
Sean said:
Yves, if you are embarking on an attached battery project in the expectation of saving a pile of money please do the maths before you commence - you won't save money (but you'll enjoy the project)

If you want to make productive use of the surplus PV generation I would suggest that a far simpler method would be load diversion to water heating, or any resistive space heater - there are numerous products that will do this very simply and (unlike a battery bank) will have a positive RoI.

If you want provide your home with energy during an incoming grid failure, buy a generator and fit a changeover switch.

I know that the math is the tricky part.

I already have an electric boiler that I can switch on in case I need, however that will not take the entire production.

The basic situation was that initially we had what was called a backwards turning meter and a yearly utility invoice. So basically nothing was required in addition to the basic solar array. The excess production would make the meter turn backwards and you could reuptake the saldo in the winter. All was fine.

My yearly consumption was ca. 7000 kWh and my yearly solar production was also around 7000 kWh. So over the last 5 years I only had to pay for an extra draw of may 100 kWh in total (due to less sun).

The electricity price is roughly around 0.25 per kWh with all the taxes and what not included. So basically I would have to pay 1750 for my electricity.

Then all started to change. They first implemented a 900 tax in solar panels.
Now they are going to implement digital meters. In essence these don't turn backward, but meter the amount of electricity injected into the grid.

They are still very quiet about how they are going to charge us, but you can bet this will not be in our favor. I think we will get 1/3 of the naked electricity price, which is roughly something like 800 out of that 1750.
I know that I have a yearly reserve for the winter of ca. 2250 kWh. 800/7000 is ca. 11,5 eurocents per kWh. 1/3 of that would be roughly 4 eurocents.

So for the 2250 extra produced electricity I would only get 90 !!!.

So the deficit would be :
To pay :
- 900 tax
- 2250 X 0,25 = 562,5 for my winter use.
Total : +- 1462 to produce my own electricity.

This is not withstand that they above is assuming that in summer I will be using up my complete need of electricity from my solar array.
To make this more practical : I use about 20 kWh a day (24 hours) on average. Of course more is using during the nights and the mornings.
The production on a sunny day is ca. 40-45 kWh that is mostly produced between 10 and 17 h. Of that 40-45 kWh I can at best use 10 kWh. The rest goes to the grid and is basically lost to me....hence the need for batteries, which will reduce my deficit to the above, otherwise it will be even bigger.

Pure ripoff.

Then there is more : if I use batteries, I could charge them in the winter when the tarifs are lower and use the cheaper electricity in the evening. It's hard to make exact calculations about this, but the numbers run up pretty fast.
 
Sean is very correct in what he says. You dont save "alot" of money on having batteries unless you enjoy the work on it or you happen to get the hardware for free or close to free :)

It though all depends on the cost of the setup and the cost of the power from the grid. I live in Sweden and if you utilize the money you get back by installing battery bank you could go +- 0 but thats over 5 or even 10 years.

Solar in Sweden is a break even on 12-18 years unless you do all job yourself.

Regarding surplus energy i made a very simple video where i utilized a raspberry pi and an ssr relay to divert energy when we have excess :)

One thing im going to use the battery bank for is to charge a future EV.
 
In winter nowhere. But during last summer i diverted it to a boiler for my shower-water.
 
I already have done that yesterday.

However, you need 3 Island inverters (one for each phase) and you also need battery chargers. Then you need to have the sma cluster controller as you don't want your battery power to end up in the grid.
One Island inverter costs 2500 minimum (lowest price I could find). So those alone cost 7500.

The plus side is they also allow the integration of a genset to take care of any shortcomings you might have. When using a genset with heat recuperation this could work out hansomly, but it will be a costly affair, even if I'm able to do most of the work.

It looks like you guys are right. Financially it's not very feasable.
So, depending whether or not the solar tax gets removed, it might be easier to just dump some solar power and take half of the panels of the roof :(
 
Yeah SMA things are not cheap :) The cheap route is like many of us do and buy the MPP stuff aside and run them. But as said you need to have a big interest in doing it. Because you dont save much :D
 
A bit more pondering from my side :)

Attached are the SMA schematics for Island operation (plus a grid for backup).

As said the SMA Island provides the possibility to control a genset as well.
I could make a genset in which in the winter I would recuperate the heat in my home heating.
If additionally to this my batteries would provide me roughly self reliance in the summer I would almost be there.

When doing this all by myself and taking into account a 24 kWh battery system from a used Nissan Leaf (which looks to be the best setup) I would be close to that and the installation cost would stay roughlyaround 20.000 - 22.000
3 sma Islands : 2500 *3 = 7500
2 battery chargers SMA at 700 = 1400
Used Nissan system : 3000
Genset : 8000
piping, heat exhanger etc. : 2000

I currently use about 2500 for home and water heating. That would rise to about 3300 in fuel costs, so 800 extra for electricity generation.

Taking into account over the next year my yearly cost to just operate my grid tied solar system would approach 2.000 a year this would mean I could potentially hit break even in 11 years on installation costs. The fuel is an extra cost, but I could charge an EV with it. The car of my wife uses about 1200 in fuel to drive to her work alone.

Hm
 

Attachments

  • schema SMA Island.pdf
    388.4 KB · Views: 282
Back
Top